Wednesday, February 1, 2023
Home Covid-19 A decade apart: Alberta families of kids killed by drunk drivers demand...

A decade apart: Alberta families of kids killed by drunk drivers demand harsher sentences

Calls for harsher sentences for impaired drivers grew after the sentencing of a Saskatchewan man who killed two teens and seriously injured a third, echoing the outcome of a similar crash that happened 10 years ago in the Edmonton region.

Christopher Rempel was sentenced to five years behind bars followed by a five-year driving prohibition for his role in a collision near Fort Saskatchewan last year.

Read more:
Saskatchewan man sentenced to 5 years in crash that killed 2 Sherwood Park teens

Keithan Peters, 16, and 17-year-old Alexandra Ollington of Sherwood Park, Alta., were killed in the crash on Highway 21 just north of Township Road 542 on Sept. 17, 2020.

Morgan Maltby, 15, was seriously injured.

Sherwood Park teens killed in Highway 21 collision remembered by friends

Sherwood Park teens killed in Highway 21 collision remembered by friends – Sep 19, 2020

“We had a meeting beforehand what the [submission for sentencing] would be. When I first heard about it, the anger and rage in me was just indescribable,” said Peters’ mother Lisa Fenez.

Story continues below advertisement

In November 2011, three teenagers were killed in a drunk-driving crash south of Edmonton near Beaumont. Jonathan Pratt was later convicted in all three of their deaths, and sentenced to an eight years.

Pratt was doing almost 200 km/h when his truck slammed into the vehicle carrying three young men, Bradley Arsenault, 18, Thaddeus Lake, 22, and Kole Novak, 18. Pratt had a blood alcohol level two-and-a-half times the legal limit.

Bradley Arsenault, Kole Novak, and Thaddeus Lake, show in a picture from a memorial held for the young men in September 2012.

Global News

‘Pathetically low for the seriousness of the crime’

Sheri Arsenault, Bradley’s mother, has been advocating for tougher impaired driving laws for years. She said the outcome of the Rempel case is reminiscent of her own experience with the justice system.

“The sentencing remains the same — pathetically low for the seriousness of the crime,” she said. “It’s almost like a calculation [of the sentencing], it never changes. Even if every judge would just give one week more, we would be up to a decent sentence in a year.”

Story continues below advertisement

Read more:
Alberta driver who killed 3 young men in 2011 crash granted day parole

She was disappointed when the Kenney government introduced legislation that added fines and penalties for first-time impaired drivers, but didn’t have them face a criminal charge.

“I’ve seen nothing but in the last eight years — federally and provincially — things going backwards,” she said.

“You almost can’t believe it that Canada’s Number 1 crime is still perceived as an accident.”

Criminal defense lawyer Ari Goldkind told Global News across Canada, there is trend of lesser and lighter sentences, rather than stricter ones — depending on demographics, income and background.

“Until someone takes a chance and goes a little bit harder… there won’t be a significant change to the sentencing principles absent parliament doing something or a judge going on a bit of a leap, but inviting the risk of a review — the risk of it being overturned or a parliamentary review.”

Click to play video: 'Alberta mother Sheri Arsenault, who lost son to a drunk driver, renews calls for changes to Criminal Code'

Alberta mother Sheri Arsenault, who lost son to a drunk driver, renews calls for changes to Criminal Code

Alberta mother Sheri Arsenault, who lost son to a drunk driver, renews calls for changes to Criminal Code – Mar 1, 2018

He said the problem will not be taken seriously nationally until judges begin to put first-time impaired driving offenders behind bars.

Story continues below advertisement

“It can’t just be the cases when someone is killed that gets Canadians talking about how serious impaired driving continues to be,” he said.

Goldkind also underscored that people typically only serve one-third of the time behind bars they’re sentenced to.

“Ten years means three and a third. Fives years means less than two,” he explained. “Many Canadians hate that, but there are good reasons for it. If you’re not a public safety risk, (it’s) to reintegrate you into society.”

Read more:
Alberta’s new, tougher impaired driving laws are in effect — here’s what you need to know

Arsenault said she believes there needs to be tougher sentencing to deter the general public from drinking and driving in the first place.

“[The justice system] is stuck in this spot. It’s textbook. That, to me, is wrong,” Arsenault said.

Story continues below advertisement

“Until this happens to someone important… then it will change.

“My child was a nobody. That’s how the whole system makes us feel. The words are there from the judge, but the action [is not].”

Both mothers believe they will be fighting for stronger sentencing for many more years to come.

“I do wish to be out there and to have a voice,” Fenez said. “Unfortunately, I have to say this… but to help the next person who deals with this.”

© 2021 Global News, a division of Corus Entertainment Inc.

Most Popular

Ontario NDP submits fresh evidence to integrity commissioner in Greenbelt investigation

The incoming leader of the Ontario NDP has submitted fresh evidence to Ontario’s integrity commissioner over the Ford government’s controversial decision to open portions...

Guelph man collects impaired driving charges while waiting for oil change

Coffee apparently wasn’t enough for a driver who was waiting on his car to get an oil change. Guelph police were notified by staff at...

McGill University temporarily shuts down 3 buildings over asbestos discovery

McGill University has closed a part of its Macdonald Campus after asbestos was discovered in a building undergoing renovations Tuesday. The Montreal institution says the...

Hamilton company to pay $175K for 2018 Lake Ontario dumping incident

A Hamilton construction company is set to pay six figures to an environmental arm of the federal government in compensation for a 2018 dumping...